The Verdict
Evidence-scored health research from Dr. Seth Holbrook, DPT.
Every popular health claim reviewed against real studies. Free to read, no email gate.
Start with the strongest evidence
Featured verdicts

Metabolic Health
90
FREE
Cholesterol — LDL, HDL, and the Statin Controversy
Lowering LDL works. Raising HDL doesn't. The "good cholesterol" framing is a marketing decision, not a scientific one.

Supplements
90
Booster
FREE
Creatine Beyond Muscle
Creatine is the most proven supplement in sports science, and its benefits go far beyond bigger muscles.

Metabolic Health
88
FREE
Blood Pressure — Lifestyle Interventions
Lifestyle changes lower blood pressure — but adherence beats stacking, and one swap has the strongest evidence.

Supplements
88
FREE
Creatine Monohydrate

Metabolic Health
87unverified sources
FREE
Water Retention Scale Weight Masking
Overnight scale jumps of 2-10 lbs are physiologically incapable of being fat. They are water, glycogen, inflammation, gut content, or medication.

Pain & Rehab
86unverified sources
FREE
Core Stability
"Core stability" as a separate skill is a refuted clinical idea. Your squat and deadlift already train your core better than any plank or bird-dog ever will.

Pain & Rehab
86
Foundation
FREE
Non-Specific Low Back Pain — Extensive Home Exercise Protocol
Lower back pain almost always gets better with movement — rest slows you down.

Pain & Rehab
86unverified sources
FREE
ACL Sprain — Prehabilitation and Return to Sport
Returning to sport before 9 months after an ACL tear multiplies re-injury risk by 7 times.

Pain & Rehab
86unverified sources
FREE
Hip Osteoarthritis — Exercise Prescription
Hip arthritis responds better to targeted exercise than to injections — and most patients never get told this.
95
clients tracked
2,000
check-ins analyzed
1,220 lb
lost by those clients
Numbers pulled live from our own coaching engine, not stock claims.
SH
Dr. Seth Holbrook, DPT
Doctor of Physical Therapy • Health & Fitness Coach • 300+ clients coached
I built The Verdict to cut through recycled health advice and show what the evidence actually supports.
Browse by topic
What are you looking for?
Pain & Rehab
Physio conditions. Exercise protocols. Red flags. Return-to-training criteria.
Supplements
Every popular supplement reviewed. Dosing, forms, safety, and what the evidence actually supports.
Sleep & Recovery
What actually helps you recover. Sleep optimization, soreness science, and recovery tools.
Performance
Training that pays off. Programming, technique debates, and what the gym myths get wrong.
Metabolic Health
Cholesterol, blood pressure, blood sugar, bloodwork: what actually moves the numbers.
Gut Health
Microbiome, fiber, probiotics: what helps your gut and what is hype.