The VerdictMODERATE CONVICTION

A sore that will not heal, or deep bone ache after surgery, needs a doctor, not exercise.

If you have a wound or ulcer over a bone that is not healing, get it looked at this week. If you can see bone in it, go today. A sore that reaches bone is treated as a bone infection until a specialist says otherwise, because in a diabetic foot that finding raises the odds of amputation almost fourfold.

  1. Here is what is really happening: an infection has got inside the bone itself, usually through a wound that will not close or an operation that left metal in a broken bone.
  2. The one thing that makes it worse: waiting. The pain often does not get worse when you use the limb, so it does not feel urgent, and that is exactly why people leave it.
  3. What to watch for: a sore deep enough that a doctor can touch bone through it. That finding alone is treated as a bone infection until proven otherwise.

Antibiotics travel through your bloodstream, so they only reach living tissue. When an infection kills a patch of bone, that patch loses its blood supply, which means the drug arrives everywhere except the one place the bacteria are living. That is why this usually needs surgery to physically remove the dead piece, and why waiting almost never works on its own.

SH
Dr. Seth Holbrook, DPT — Doctor of Physical Therapy • Coach to 300+ clients
I built The Verdict to cut through recycled health advice and show what the evidence actually supports.

Systemic · Bone Infection

Osteomyelitis

An infection living inside a bone. It does not behave like a normal injury, it cannot be treated with exercise, and it is most often found either under a foot ulcer that will not heal or around metalwork after a fracture.

CONVICTION: MODERATE

If you have a wound or ulcer over a bone that is not healing, get it looked at this week. If you can see bone in it, go today.

A sore deep enough to reach bone is treated as a bone infection until a specialist says otherwise. In a diabetic foot, that finding raises the odds of amputation almost fourfold.

Takes one phone call. No equipment needed.

A sore that will not heal, or deep bone ache after surgery, needs a doctor, not exercise.

Antibiotics travel through your bloodstream, so they only reach living tissue. When an infection kills a patch of bone, that patch loses its blood supply, which means the drug arrives everywhere except the one place the bacteria are actually living. That is why this usually needs surgery to physically remove the dead piece, and why waiting almost never works on its own.

  1. Here is what is really happening: an infection has got inside the bone itself, usually through a wound that will not close or an operation that left metal in a broken bone.
  2. The one thing that makes it worse: waiting. The pain often does not get worse when you use the limb, so it never feels urgent, and that is exactly why people leave it for months.
  3. What to watch for: a sore deep enough that a doctor can touch bone through it. That one finding is treated as a bone infection until proven otherwise.

Best for

Anyone with a non-healing wound over a bone, or deep unexplained bone pain after a fracture operation, who wants to know how urgent this is.

Skip if

Your pain is in your spine. That is a different condition with different tests. And nothing here replaces being seen, because this is not a self-treatment protocol.

Want the full evidence? Keep scrolling

What Works

Dark cinematic surgical anatomy of bone debridement

There is no physical therapy treatment for bone infection. Nothing in the physical therapy toolkit clears a biofilm on dead bone. This hierarchy is medical and surgical, recorded so you know what happens after the referral.

Surgical removal of all infected and dead bone STRONG

Source control is the treatment. Pooled cure 91 percent across 42 studies and 1,605 patients, with no significant difference between single-stage and two-stage surgery (Lari 2024).

Expected timeline: months, not weeks.

Culture-directed antibiotics, sampled before empiric treatment STRONG

Targeting requires a sample. Starting antibiotics first can make that sample uninformative (IWGDF/IDSA 2023, Senneville 2024).

Complete margin clearance in the diabetic foot MODERATE

Infected bone left at the resection margin raises amputation risk 4.3-fold (95% CI 2.4 to 7.6), re-infection 2.0-fold, and adds 16.3 days of antibiotics (Reyes 2024).

Non-removable knee-high offloading for a neuropathic plantar ulcer STRONG

First choice per the IWGDF 2023 guideline (Bus 2024). Healing risk ratio 1.24 (95% CI 1.09 to 1.41) versus removable devices. Carry the cost with it: device-related complications risk ratio 1.70, and wearers move measurably less.

Healing measured at 12 and 20 weeks.

Tier 2 and Tier 3 — reconstruction, local antibiotics, and the one study with physical therapy in it

Antibiotic-loaded calcium sulfate at debridement MODERATE

Overall eradication 92 percent across 16 studies and 917 patients (Shi 2022). Non-randomised series.

Staged reconstruction of segmental defects MODERATE

Induced-membrane (Masquelet) technique: union 89.7 percent and infection eradication 91.1 percent across 427 patients, but persistence of infection or non-union in 18 percent requiring further surgery, and patients operated for infection had significantly higher complication risk (Morelli 2016).

Physical therapy inside a multidisciplinary protocol EMERGING

The only retrieved study with physical therapy in the protocol is a Red Cross cohort in the Democratic Republic of Congo: 168 treated, 71 reviewed at mean 13.7 months, clinical cure 63.4 percent but good functional improvement in only 50.7 percent (Baldan 2014). One observational cohort in an austere setting. Its value is the gap it exposes, not the protocol it describes.

What Doesn't Work

  • Exercise, loading, or manual therapy as treatment for the infection. Loading a structurally weakened infected bone risks it breaking.
  • A trial of treatment while you see how it goes. Every week of delay is measured against an amputation odds ratio of 3.87 in the diabetic foot, and against a falling implant-retention success rate around metalwork.
  • Using a normal X-ray or a normal blood test as permission to keep treating conservatively. The X-ray misses roughly 4 in 10. Around metalwork, the blood tests miss more than half.
  • Borrowing an antibiotic duration from a headline. The pooled figures in this literature reverse inside their own subgroups.

Exercise Prescription

Nothing below treats the infection. It exists because the offloading device that heals ulcers best is also the one whose wearers move least, and because a systematic review that screened 3,332 records found no study has ever tested a rehabilitation programme for this condition (Jones 2023). Every item is a reasoned response to a measured problem, not a proven treatment. Your medical team's instructions override all of it, and nothing loads the affected limb until they say so.

ExerciseSets × RepsFrequencyPain guide
Seated arm press
Sitting tall, press the weight straight overhead and lower under control
3 × 10-123 days a weekEffort in shoulders and arms. Nothing at the affected limb
Seated row with a band
Pull the band towards your ribs, squeezing the shoulder blades
3 × 10-123 days a weekEffort between the shoulder blades only
Unaffected-leg sit-to-stand
Stand from a firm chair using only the good leg, lower slowly
3 × 8-10DailyEffort in the good thigh. Keep all weight off the affected limb
Seated arm cycling or brisk arm swings
Any continuous arm movement that gets you slightly breathless
10-20 minMost daysAble to talk but not sing

Red Flags

Dark cinematic anatomical study of infected bone tissue
Refer — do not treat

Same day · emergency department

Fever, shivering, confusion, or feeling systemically unwell. A rapidly spreading red limb. A foot that becomes cold, pale or numb in a way it was not before.

Same day · specialist foot service

An ulcer that a probe touches bone through. Visible bone at the base of a wound. A sinus discharging over bone or over metalwork.

This week · urgent orthopaedic

Deep, unremitting bone pain after fracture surgery, with or without fever. The clock matters: keeping the metal in succeeds in 86 to 100 percent of cases revised within three weeks of the infection starting, and 82 to 89 percent at three to ten weeks. Later is worse.

Absence does not reassure

  • Fever is commonly absent in chronic bone infection and in late infection around metalwork.
  • A normal X-ray does not exclude it. It misses roughly four cases in ten.
  • A normal blood test does not exclude it around metalwork. ESR catches fewer than half of these cases.

Refer to: diabetic foot with any suspicion of bone involvement, same-day multidisciplinary diabetic foot service or emergency department out of hours. Suspected infection around fracture metalwork, urgent referral to the treating orthopaedic team, naming infection in the referral. Systemic illness, emergency department now. Do not route any of these through a routine appointment in two weeks.

Return to Training

Every box is set by the treating team, not by how the limb feels. This is not a pain-guided progression.

Conviction

Overall MODERATE, split across nine claims. Actionability splits two ways and must not be averaged: MODERATE for recognition and referral, NOT ACTIONABLE for treatment.

ClaimConviction
Bone infection substantially raises amputation risk in a diabetic foot ulcer (OR 3.87, 95% CI 2.28-6.57)HIGH
Test accuracy differs by skeletal site and by population for the same testHIGH
MRI is the most accurate widely available scan for diabetes-related foot bone infectionHIGH
A normal X-ray does not exclude itHIGH
Blood tests are insufficient to diagnose late infection around fracture metalworkMODERATE
Probe-to-bone is useful at the bedside, conditional on the settingMODERATE
Earlier revision after fixation infection retains implants more oftenMODERATE
Any specific antibiotic duration or route for peripheral disease in adultsLOW
Any rehabilitation protocol for this conditionNOT ACTIONABLE
What would change my mind — the probe-to-bone claim

A prospective study of probe-to-bone and blood markers run in a primary-contact musculoskeletal setting rather than a specialist service: consecutive adults with non-mechanical limb pain, N of at least 1,500 to accumulate enough cases at realistic rates, MRI or bone biopsy as the reference, reporting positive predictive value and the number needed to refer per case detected. That number does not currently exist anywhere in this literature, and it is the one a physical therapist actually needs. It would move this claim to HIGH or retire it.

What would change my mind — the "no rehabilitation evidence" claim

A randomised trial of a structured rehabilitation programme during and after offloading for diabetes-related foot ulceration, N of at least 300, non-removable knee-high device in both arms, with a defined upper-body and seated aerobic programme plus a staged post-device weight-bearing progression. Co-primary endpoints: ulcer healing at 12 weeks (non-inferiority) and objectively measured physical activity (superiority), with falls and new lesions as safety endpoints. This is the single trial that would create a genuine physical therapy role in this condition.

The Full Picture — Anatomy, Diagnosis & Evidence

What's Actually Going On

Dark cinematic cross-section of bone and marrow

Bacteria reach bone by three routes. Spreading from an adjacent soft-tissue infection is the dominant route in the diabetic foot: the ulcer comes first, the bone infection follows. Direct inoculation happens at the moment of an open fracture or during fixation surgery. Seeding through the bloodstream dominates in children and in spinal disease, both outside this page.

Once established, the organisms build a biofilm, a protective layer, on dead bone and on any implanted metal. This is the single fact that explains the whole condition. Biofilm survives antibiotic concentrations far above the level that kills the same organism free-floating, which is why physically removing the infected tissue does more of the work than choosing the right drug.

Dead bone, called a sequestrum, has no blood supply. Antibiotics travel in blood. The drug arrives everywhere except where the infection lives.

How to Identify It

Dark cinematic clinical study of a foot examination

How good each test is at catching this, and at ruling it out:

  • Probe-to-bone Sn: 0.60-0.87 | Sp: 0.83-0.91
    The one bedside test that matters. Two published pooled sensitivities sit 27 points apart (Dinh 2008 at 0.60, Lam 2016 at 0.87), and Lam states outright that the test rules in where the disease is common and rules out where it is rare. Neither figure is the test's accuracy. Both are its accuracy in a setting.
  • MRI Sn: 96.4% | Sp: 83.8%
    The most accurate widely available scan for the diabetic foot (Llewellyn 2020). Specificity falls to 60 percent in long-standing disease, and it cannot always separate infection from a Charcot foot.
  • Plain X-ray Sn: 54-62% | Sp: 68-78%
    Misses roughly four cases in ten. A normal film excludes very little.
  • ESR blood test Foot: AUC 0.83 | Metalwork: Sn 45.1%
    The most setting-dependent number on this page. Best of the blood markers in the diabetic foot (Ansert 2024, van Asten 2016), close to uninformative around fracture metalwork (van den Kieboom 2018).

The Debate

Oral antibiotics: non-inferior, or not?

Lima 2025, 9 RCTs, 1,723 patients

Oral versus intravenous, treatment failure RR 0.96 (95% CI 0.78-1.17). No difference.

vs

Lima 2025, same analysis, FRI excluded

RR 1.47 (95% CI 1.08-2.02, p=0.02), favouring intravenous.

These are the same paper. The headline non-inferiority is carried by the fracture-related subgroup. Read the subgroup before applying the headline.

Short antibiotic courses: safe, or not?

Huang 2019, 15 studies, 3,598 patients

Short versus long course, failure OR 1.50 (95% CI 0.97-2.34). Not significant.

vs

Huang 2019, spinal subgroup

OR 2.06 (95% CI 1.18-3.57). Short courses fail in spinal disease.

Again one paper. The pooled null is a mixture of a real spinal signal and a null childhood one, and neither of those populations is this page's.

Honest Limitations

The outcome literature does not agree what the disease is

The research finding: pooled cure rates of 91 percent and eradication rates of 92 percent look like precise, comparable numbers.

The real-world gap: Metsemakers 2018 reviewed 100 randomised trials on fracture fixation. Two cited a validated definition of infection. Seventy gave none at all in their methods while reporting infection as a result. Bezstarosti 2019 found the same across 93 treatment studies and 3,701 patients: one study used a standard definition, and nine different classification systems were in use.

Clinical adjustment: quote the direction, not the decimal. Most people do well, and the published number is less precise than it looks.

Every accuracy figure was measured where the disease is far more common

The research finding: probe-to-bone 0.87, MRI 96.4 percent, ESR AUC 0.83.

The real-world gap: these come almost entirely from specialist diabetic foot services and orthopaedic trauma units. A clinician seeing undifferentiated musculoskeletal pain works where this is orders of magnitude rarer, and no study reports accuracy in that setting. There is no published number needed to refer per case detected. That cost is unquantified, not acceptable.

Clinical adjustment: use these tests to raise or lower suspicion in someone who already has a wound or metalwork. Do not deploy them as a screen across a general caseload.

The physical therapy intervention has never been tested

The research finding: Jones 2023 searched four databases and trial registries to September 2022 and screened 3,332 records, including eight studies covering 441 participants.

The real-world gap: none of the eight delivered or tested a structured rehabilitation programme. The same review found the device with the best healing evidence is also the device whose wearers move least (SMD -0.45, 95% CI -0.87 to -0.04, p=0.03). The standard of care creates a measured fitness problem in people for whom inactivity is a reversible risk, and nobody has run the trial.

Clinical adjustment: not tested and failed. Not tested. Anything offered here is reasoned, and it has to be labelled that way to the patient.

The Nuance

Dark cinematic comparative anatomy of skeletal regions

The same test has a different accuracy in a different bone, and the disease has one name. Termaat 2005 pooled leukocyte scintigraphy, a scan that tracks labelled white blood cells to the site of infection, and reported 84 percent sensitivity in the arms and legs and 21 percent in the spine. One review, one pooling, one disease name, and a fourfold difference by location.

That is why this page covers the appendicular skeleton only and hands all spinal disease to a separate protocol. It is not a filing convenience. A clinician who borrows a number across that boundary is using a test that does not work where they are using it.

Curing the infection and restoring the limb are different outcomes. In the one retrieved cohort that measured both, the infection was cured in 63.4 percent and function meaningfully improved in 50.7 percent (Baldan 2014). Roughly one patient in eight got the first without the second. Curing the infection is the surgeon's job and it usually works. What happens to the limb afterwards is where the evidence stops.

Surgery versus conservative: in long-bone disease with dead bone, source control is the treatment, and pooled cure is 91 percent across 1,605 patients with at least 12 months of follow-up. Complications were reported in 26.6 percent of single-stage procedures. In the diabetic foot, medical management without surgery is a genuine option in selected cases under a multidisciplinary service.

Sources

Go Deeper

Most injury advice never tells you which problems are not injuries at all. The Verdict reviews one condition or supplement a week, with the evidence graded and the gaps named. Free.

Join The Verdict

Dealing with something specific?

Every pain and rehab verdict, evidence-scored: what actually speeds recovery, what to skip, and when to get it checked.

Browse Pain & Rehab verdicts
Or find your lane in 2 questions

Get weekly evidence-based rehab verdicts

Physio conditions reviewed against clinical evidence. What works, what doesn't, and what to do — from a practising physiotherapist.

Subscribe free

Want a coach, not just research?

The Verdict is built by the same team behind Precision Metrics — a physique and health coaching practice with 300+ clients coached. Dr. Seth Holbrook, DPT and Luke Holbrook lead the coaching.

Book a free consultation

Related free research

Pain & Rehab
Accessory Deep Peroneal Nerve — The Verdict
Pain & Rehab
Dorsal Foot and Ankle Bone Spurs as a Nerve-Compression Cause — The Verdict
Pain & Rehab
Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease — The Verdict

There are 500+ more inside

Conviction-scored verdicts on supplements, nutrition, training, physio, and recovery.

Explore all Get weekly verdicts